Bob Pease | Electronic Design
66280493f24a4a001e387018 Whats All This K2w Stuff Anyhow Part 2

What's All This K2-W Stuff, Anyhow? (Part 2)

Feb. 3, 2003
Here are some additional comments on the K2-W that did not fit in last month's column.
Bob Pease | Electronic Design
Analog

What's All This K2-W Stuff, Anyhow? (Part 2) (Download)

Login or sign up to download this free PDF version of the article.

Here are some additional comments on the K2-W that did not fit in What's All This K2-W Stuff, Anyhow? | Electronic Design (Electronic Design, Jan. 6, p. 20). The K2-W had adequate gain and dc stability, and it was fast enough for many analog computing schemes—100 times faster than the M-IX amplifier mentioned in Part 1.

Uses: George A. Philbrick Researches, at 127-129 Clarendon St., implemented hundreds of K2-W's each month in the popular analog computing modules, such as the K5-U, K5-M, and so forth. That got the production volume up.

What if you did not like the offset drift to be ±50 mV per day? Philbrick would be happy to sell you an add-on K2-P Chopper-Stabilizing Amplifier, to cut the drift to below 1/2 mV per day—and that's not too bad stability referred to full scale! It was priced at$54.

What if you wanted more output swing than the paltry ±50 V? For $33, you could swap in, to the same socket, a K2-X or K2-XA that would swing ±100 V at up to 3.3 mA. Not too poor. In fact, many modern operational amplifiers are not rated to drive 330 mW!

A $400 R-300 power supply would provide enough power for 70 K2-W's, so the 'W really was light on its feet in terms of power needs.) One reason why the R-300 was so good in its accuracy and stability was so that it could compensate for the K2-W's lousy PSRR. This ALSO was never specified, but it was about 18 dB.

Note: Walter Jung has written a very good chapter on the history of op amps, in a new book, Op Amp Applications, published by Analog Devices. The cost is $22. That's no more than the price of a K2-W! The chapter includes Walt's comments on the K2-W, plus a photo and schematic of the unit.

A SUSPICION NOT UPHELD: I finally got some data on the K2-W. I was really expecting Zout to be lousy, worse than the data-sheet value of 1 Ω, because the K2-W's gain of 10,000 minimum does rely a lot on the Positive Feedback from the 221 k resistor. I was thinking that the output did not have much gm. But actually, the cathode-follower output did a pretty good job. Zout (closed-loop, as a unity-gain follower) was about 0.24 Ω. So I'm pleased to see where my erroneous thinking was corrected!

Note: In the schematic, the balanced input stage went to a single-sided level shifter down to the grid of the second stage, down near +2 V. This stage gets positive feedback from the output follower, via 221 kΩ, which was required to get the gain up from 4000 to 20,000. Note also the 15-pF Miller capacitor around the second stage, and the two NE-2 neon lamps used as level-changers to the grid of the output follower. (The op amps in the Heathkit analog computer were the same, except they used three 52-V zeners—Ha!

WHAT ABOUT THE PACKAGING? The components of the K2-W were ingeniously hay-wired over a jig. Of course, everything was carefully hand-soldered. Then it was closed up inside two plastic shell halves. The K2-W's octal base plugged into the user's socket, and the nine-pin tubes plugged in at the top. The whole thing stood just 4.1 in above the chassis. Not bad for $22.

Comments invited! [email protected] —or:
Mail Stop D2597A, National Semiconductor
P.O. Box 58090, Santa Clara, CA 95052-8090

Bob Pease | Electronic Design
About the Author

Bob Pease

Bob obtained a BSEE from MIT in 1961 and was a staff scientist at National Semiconductor Corp., Santa Clara, CA, for many years. He was a well known and long time contributing editor to Electronic Design.

We also have a number of PDF eBooks by Bob that members can download from the Electronic Design Members Library.

Sponsored Recommendations

Comments

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Electronic Design, create an account today!