Dreamstime_bulatsilvia_166657452
66be756352cc42d073731aa1 Dreamstime Bulatsilvia 166657452

Comparing Photodiodes: GaN PIN Avalanche vs. PIN (Download)

Aug. 15, 2024
Log in to download the PDF of this article comparing GaN PIN photodiodes and PIN photodiodes.

Read this article online.

Major differences exist between a PIN photodiode and an avalanche photodiode (APD), such as:

  • Gain isn’t provided in a PIN photodiode; however, high gain and high speed via an internal gain mechanism is provided in an APD.
  • An undoped intrinsic layer is strategically placed between two highly doped regions in a PIN diode, whereas a π layer is positioned between a p and n region in an APD.
  • An amplifier is necessary to connect externally for a PIN diode, but no external amplifier is needed in an APD.
  • A PIN diode has less response time, while an APD offers a very fast response time.
  • PIN diodes have a small output current; APDs have higher output current.
  • In a PIN diode, different noise currents are photon noise, shot noise, Johnson noise, and generation recombination noise. APDs have different noise currents such as shot noise, thermal noise, and avalanche noise.
  • PIN diodes have shot current of Ishot = √2qIDB; APDs have shot current of Ishot = √2q (Iph + IB + ID)G2FB.
  • PIN diodes have less sensitivity, while APDs possess higher sensitivity to detect very low light levels.
  • PIN diodes need a low reverse bias; APDs require high reverse bias.
  • PIN diodes have good temperature stability; APDs have poor stability.

Comments

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Electronic Design, create an account today!